The Hall of Fame honors individuals of noteworthy athletic achievement at Albertus Magnus College.
The first-ever induction into the Hall of Fame was in 2008.
The Hall of Fame is located in the Cosgrove, Marcus, Messer Athletic Center and includes the Hall of Fame display centerpiece and plaques.
Hall of Fame Criteria and Nomination Process
| NAME | INDUCTION YEAR | SPORT/AFFILIATION | ||
| Michael Abbey | 2014 | Men's Soccer | ||
| Ryan Antonino | 2018 | Baseball | ||
| Ray Askew | 2018 | Men's Basketball | ||
| George Bedocs | 2008 | Men's Soccer, Head Coach | ||
| Sr. Charles Marie Brantl, O.P.* | 2014 | Friend/Supporter of Athletics | ||
| Lianna Carrero | 2020/2022 | Women's Basketball | ||
| Michael Choiniere | 2020/2022 | Men's Lacrosse | ||
| Andrew Cicarella | 2009 | Baseball | ||
| Victor Crespo | 2016 | Men's Soccer | ||
| Jason Crockett | 2018 | Men's Basketball | ||
| Samantha Farley | 2018 | Women's Soccer | ||
| Jim Ferraro | 2009 | Women's Basketball, Head Coach | ||
| Candice Giordano Damico | 2011 | Softball & Women's Volleyball | ||
| Mark Giordano | 2016 | Softball, Head Coach | ||
| Patrick Good | 2016 | Men's Basketball, Baseball | ||
| Nick Hamasian | 2020/2022 | Men's Soccer | ||
| Jamal Howard | 2020/2022 | Men's Soccer | ||
| Liz Lacroix | 2008 | Women's Basketball | ||
| Karen Lobasz | 2008 | Women's Basketball | ||
| Tabitha "Wazorko" Manafort | 2020/2022 | Softball & Women's Basketball | ||
| Jeanne Mann | 2016 | Administrator | ||
| Natalia Perlaza | 2011 | Women's Basketball | ||
| Brian Puzycki | 2014 | Men's Basketball | ||
| Frank Raio* | 2014 | Men's Soccer, Ast. Coach | ||
| Tim Russell | 2011 | Men's Basketball | ||
| Walden St. Juste | 2020/2022 | Men's Basketball | ||
| Joseph Tonelli | 2008 | Baseball, Head Coach & Athletic Director | ||
| Jaqhawn Walters* | 2020/2022 | Men's Basketball | ||
| Darius Watson | 2020/2022 | Men's Basketball | ||
| Jay Wyatt | 2011 | Baseball | ||
| Stephen Zapata | 2018 | Men's Soccer | ||
| 1994-95 Women's Basketball | 2009 | Women's Basketball | ||
| Denise Brace | ||||
| Diana Burroughs | ||||
| Megan Callahan | ||||
| Heather Fenn | ||||
| Jessica Flood | ||||
| Kathy Gauthier | ||||
| Liz Lacroix | ||||
| Karen Lobasz | ||||
| Christie Matteo | ||||
| Kim Pofok | ||||
| Lisa Ranciato | ||||
| Head Coach: Jim Ferraro | ||||
| 1996 Men's Soccer | 2008 | Men's Soccer | ||
| Victor Alves | ||||
| Donald Anderson | ||||
| James Bernardo | ||||
| Shane Bryan | ||||
| William “Casey” Cahoon | ||||
| Victor Crespo | ||||
| Gabriel DeMello | ||||
| Vincent DeStefanis | ||||
| Edward Easter | ||||
| Christopher Everone | ||||
| John Gilbey | ||||
| Kevin Guarino | ||||
| Jason Kelly | ||||
| Jay Kopchinski | ||||
| Matthew Monroy | ||||
| Daniel O’Connor | ||||
| Joseph Quinn | ||||
| Head Coach: George Bedocs | ||||
| * inducted posthumously | ||||
